A look back: underwood's stirring Sound of Music stint on NBC

    Revisiting Carrie Underwood’s unforgettable night in NBC’s live "The Sound of Music" - a blend of triumph and trial.

    <p>Carrie Underwood</p>

    Carrie Underwood

    A decade ago, Carrie Underwood stepped into a role that was both daunting and exhilarating, leading NBC's live staging of "The Sound of Music." This bold undertaking showcased Underwood in a light far removed from her country music stronghold, embarking on a journey through the hallowed notes of a Broadway classic. The show, while "not perfect, or even really good," was undeniably a cozy television experience, reminiscent of "singing ‘My Favorite Things’ while riding out a thunderstorm."

    Underwood's Performance: Singing High, Acting Low

    While Underwood's vocal prowess was never in question, her acting chops faced scrutiny. With "braids wrapped around her head like a barmaid," she delivered on the musical front but struggled in the acting department, turning every spoken scene into an "on-the-fly translation emergency." This contrast was starkly evident when juxtaposed with the seasoned brilliance of Broadway veterans like Audra McDonald, whose rendition of “Climb Every Mountain” was so powerful it reportedly brought tears to Underwood’s eyes.

    Underwood's portrayal of Maria was a crucial element, but when it faltered, the show subtly shifted focus, highlighting performances from other cast members. Despite these challenges, the production as a whole brought a unique, almost community theater-like charm to mainstream television, relying on the audience's "better angels" to look past its imperfections.

    Reflecting on the Production: A Year Later

    Now, looking back at this ambitious production, it stands as a testament to Underwood’s willingness to step out of her comfort zone and the inherent risks of live performances. The show not only entertained but also initiated discussions on the merits of celebrity casting in theater. It was a night that saw a country star reach for the Broadway stars, leaving an indelible mark on the landscape of live musical television.

    Disclaimer: Several parts of the text in this article, including the title, were generated with the help of an AI tool.