When Carrie Underwood's Sound of Music role stirred Von Trapp Family concern

The announcement of Carrie Underwood playing Maria von Trapp in NBC's live television event of The Sound of Music stirred a blend of anticipation and controversy. The Von Trapp family, whose story inspired the beloved 1965 film, voiced their apprehensions about the Grammy-winner's portrayal of their matriarch. Myles von Trapp Derbyshire, the great-grandson of Maria von Trapp, shared his candid thoughts with ABC News. "It's just upsetting that this could potentially be the final broadcast of our story," he said, questioning Underwood's suitability for the role due to her lack of acting experience and her image as a country music star and tabloid figure.

The family's skepticism about Underwood's casting wasn't just about her musical background. They compared her to Julie Andrews and Mary Martin, both well-respected actresses who previously played Maria. “Our family has had the conversations of who could play this role better, and it was Anne Hathaway, for example," Myles added, referencing Hathaway's Oscar-winning performance in Les Miserables.

Also read: Tuned to generosity: When Bradley Cooper joined star-studded auction for covid relief 

Carrie Underwood responds to backlash

Underwood, aware of the fans' protective sentiment over the original movie, addressed the backlash in an interview with Entertainment Weekly. "I get hate tweets and stuff like that and like, 'You're not Julie Andrews!'" she shared, acknowledging her awareness of not being able to replace Andrews but still respecting her own place in the role. Despite the criticism, Underwood remained committed to the role, albeit with apprehensions about the acting part of the live musical. The situation highlighted the challenges faced by artists stepping into roles much beloved and associated with iconic performances.

A delicate balance between legacy and innovation

The remake of The Sound of Music was a venture balancing respect for a timeless classic with the desire to introduce it to a new generation. As the Von Trapp family grappled with the portrayal of their story and Underwood faced the pressure of stepping into big shoes, the event underscored the complexities of reimagining iconic stories. Myles von Trapp Derbyshire's initial inclination to boycott the broadcast softened after discussions with his mother, who encouraged a more open-minded approach. "We need to be educated," he concluded, recognizing the importance of understanding the new adaptation to engage in informed discussions.

Also read: A look back: underwood's stirring Sound of Music stint on NBC 

Reflecting on The Sound of Music live event

Looking back, Carrie Underwood's role in the live television event of The Sound of Music became more than just a performance; it was a moment that sparked conversations about artistic interpretation, legacy, and the challenges of meeting fan expectations while trying to bring a fresh perspective to a beloved story.

(Several parts of the text in this article, including the title, were generated with the help of an AI tool.)